What Can Jules Verne Tell Us About Space Exploration?
Why is Jules Verne’s 160-year-old satirical novel, From the Earth to the Moon, still relevant to modern space debates?
On this episode, host Jason Lloyd is joined by G. Ryan Faith, a former staff member on the US House of Representatives Space and Aeronautics Subcommittee, the Space Foundation, and the Center for Strategic and International Studies. In the Fall 2026 Issues, Faith reviewed a new edition of the book edited by Anastasia Klimchynskaya. This comic tale inspired many rocket science pioneers to work on the problem of space travel, and still offers inspiration for discussing modern space policies.
Resources
- Check out G. Ryan Faith’s review of the book in our Fall 2026 issue.
- Does space exploration need philosophy and imagination? Read Faith’s Issues article from 2024, “Taking Aristotle to the Moon and Beyond.”
Transcript
Jason Lloyd: Welcome to The Ongoing Transformation, a podcast from Issues in Science and Technology. Issues is a quarterly journal published by the National Academy of Sciences and Arizona State University.
I’m Jason Lloyd, managing editor of Issues. Jules Verne began writing his series of extraordinary voyages in 1863. The series would eventually include some of his most famous novels, such as Journey to the Center of the Earth, Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea, and Around the World in Eighty Days. The fourth novel in the series, published in 1865, was From the Earth to the Moon, which chronicled the activities of the Baltimore Gun Club. With little to do following the Civil War, the bored artillerymen developed a plan to blast a projectile to the moon.
Book Excerpt: “I find that a projectile endowed with an initial velocity of 12,000 yards per second and aimed at the moon must necessarily reach it. I have the honor, my brave colleagues, to propose a trial of this little experiment.”
Jason Lloyd: As the first volume in its Imagination, Annotated series, MIT Press published an annotated edition of Verne’s novel, edited by Anastasia Klimchynskaya earlier this year. I’m joined today by Ryan Faith, who reviewed the book in the Fall 2026 Issues in Science and Technology. Ryan, thank you so much for joining us. To start, could you tell us a little bit about this edition that you reviewed? It’s kind of a layered text.
Ryan Faith: There’s three layers to this. There’s the text, the annotations, and the commentary essays, and to sort of expand this a little bit is that Jules Verne has suffered a lot from really butchered translations in the US, and those are still circulated, and those tend to frame it as an adventure story, something that’s very shallow, that’s not really got a lot of depth. And so Klimchynskaya went and used the canonical Miller translation, did huge amounts of background research, so the text proper that you’re getting is actually a very good, rich, and complete version. And then throughout that, she and some other folks made annotations and commentary, and then finally we have the sets of essays by some people who commented, also contributed essays, and there’s partial overlap between those two sets.
Jason Lloyd: And so what, kind of in very broad outline, what is Verne’s story? What’s the plot?
Ryan Faith: So Verne’s story is primarily educational, didactic, and so it’s sort of a piece in which we can go along and then have some sort of burst of explanation, right? And so, there’s a lot of talk about whether or not Verne is satire, and Verne’s base purpose is educational, but he uses a lot of humor modes on top of that. So in the book, you have this bunch of artillerists from the US Civil War, ‘cause this book came out in 1865 at the end of the US Civil War. And these artillerists are bored and have nothing to do and have no guns to build, and for lack of anything better to do, decided to build a gun to shoot something to the moon, to shoot a projectile to the moon.
And there’s a couple things that are sort of critical with this, that the Americans are portrayed, I think, in a very humorous fashion. And so the satire comes in very heavy because you need to make these people utterly preposterous, because this is a preposterous, insane, almost effectively stupid idea that only an American would be dumb enough to try and then actually pull off, right? And so that sort of sets up a lot, and that’s where you start getting this tension about whether or not the book is serious or whether or not it’s humorous and so on and so forth. I suppose the shortest descriptions would be that it, in modern terms, would be Jackass as supervised by MythBusters. So that’s the core of it.
Book Excerpt: “‘You know,’ said he, ‘what progress artillery science has made during the last few years, and what a degree of perfection firearms of every kind have reached. Moreover, you are well aware that in general terms, the resisting power of cannon and the expansive force of gunpowder are practically unlimited. Well, starting from this principle, I ask myself whether, supposing sufficient apparatus could be obtained, constructed upon the conditions of ascertained resistance, it might not be possible to project a shot up to the moon?’”
Jason Lloyd: You touch on this in your review, but it has some very prescient aspects to the actual mission to the moon.
Ryan Faith: So, the notable sort of landmark feature of the book from one perspective is that it was the first to sort of really wed technology and numbers and education to this process, because you’ve got a huge history of journeys to space going back to, like Lucian of Samosata and, you know, all of these things. So it’s not a new story, but this is the first time somebody is also trying to import this numbers and reckoning into it. And it causes a little bit of, I think, a misreading of what’s going on for some people, because they want to look at Verne as a science fiction author, and then they say, “Okay, so he’s prescient, so he’s using all of this stuff to go write about space, ‘cause he’s like a space guy.”
And it’s like, well, space for him was really actually kind of incidental, you know? He’s writing about around the world, you know, hot air balloons. He’s writing about all of these different technological things, so he was just sort of looking for different kinds of expression. It’s a little bit like Michael Crichton writes novel, wrote novels, you know? He’s just sort of got this, “I am gonna go write about a technological topic, and this is the one I have.”
Um, but because he’s the first to really sort of apply, you know, actual numbers and some more rigorous engineering, well, not the first, but he’s best known for it, is people have tended to almost retroactively interpret that as him trying to conceive of a space program, right? That he’s like a space guy, and then he’s gonna figure out how you do this and all this stuff. And it’s like, well, no, he’s trying to teach people in France about science and technology, and this book happened to be the one that was about space. But it was kind of really crazy and effectively a pretty dumb idea to shoot people to the moon, so we’re gonna, like, make these Americans, like, just bonkers and wave our hands a lot, and then we can get to our technological or educational explanations throughout the text.
Jason Lloyd: Yeah. So in the story, did they actually send people to the moon?
Ryan Faith: So in the story, they didn’t intend to send people to the moon. They first were just going to go shoot a gun at the moon because, you know, why not? Um, and then later on, they have an even more preposterous French daredevil who sort of insists on and makes turning this into a crewed flight. They don’t land on the moon at any point. They are supposed to go around the moon. In this book, in this particular volume, they get to the firing of the gun and then basically cut.
And then the sequel, which was written five years later, they actually go around the moon. It’s a way for Verne to bring in talk about science and astronomy at the time, and then you can start seeing that he’s like, “Oh, well now I’m going to have this debate between these two characters so I can discuss this theory,” and so on and so forth.
Jason Lloyd: So the book came out in 1865. Obviously, this was long before, you know, any sort of space program in the United States. Could you talk about just sort of what influence the book had or your sense of the influence the book had after publication?
Ryan Faith: Well, it was very influential for the generation of people who started developing the rockets or at least the rocket theory that then eventually led to the space program. So folks like Robert Goddard and Hermann Oberth all read this as a child. And one of the theories that’s put forward about the book is that the book was inaccurate, but since it had all of this sort of numbers and technological substrate and structure to it, that it inspired these people to figure out and calculate how it was done correctly. So they took the book as a lead convincing them to go treat this as an analytical problem than rather this like purely fictional hand-waving problem.
Jason Lloyd: Yeah. So just to get back to this particular volume, how do the various contributors to this edition approach the text? What kinds of things do they focus on?
Ryan Faith: So you have sort of two schools of essay and commentary. One is approaching it from what I’d sort of describe as a fairly, you know, typical historical text in a sense. You know, it’s like, okay, this was important for this, or we’re going to look at this aspect of it. The second comes at it from something that’s, I think, a lot more of the critical tradition, and this is where I think the editor may have been sort of put between a rock and a hard spot because the series, you know, the Imagination, Annotated, is supposed to be using these science fiction texts to sort of foreground and center certain kinds of debates. So throughout what we see in this is that there’s sort of a split personality between this very critical approach and this very sort of traditional-historical approach. And I think where that causes difficulty is that it changes voice without necessarily announcing that it’s changing voice.
It’s not like, okay, right, for this chapter, I’ve got my critical hat on. For this chapter, I’ve got my history hat on. They kind of swap between the two perspectives, and I think that that’s sort of an unfortunate pressure that was sort of put on the editor and is a difficult one to resolve. And one of the things that I think the edition missed, which was unfortunate, was that this was written in 1865 at the end of the Civil War. So the French writers are reacting to the US Civil War, and there’s a good guy and a bad guy, and the good guy was the North and the bad guy was the South. And so there’s a couple places where he’s clearly, you know, admitting or stating a moral or ethical stance. And when you then view this only in the colonial lens, you miss that. That gets pulled out.
So he’s got a part where he’s talking about the town where they built this gun as being this big paradise of equality and competency and brotherhood and workmanship, and then the annotation, because it’s locked in this critical mode, says they failed to mention all of these things that were terrible, you know, for Blacks in the US at this time. And it’s like, well, that’s true, but that’s losing the spirit in which it was written.
Jason Lloyd: Yeah. One of the things I really like about the review is that you sort of create this tension between the people you call astrofuturists and their critics as a way to sort of look at this book, and I was wondering if you could talk about who the astrofuturists are, and then maybe what their critics think.
Ryan Faith: If you look at the history of the space program up until the Space Race, right, you don’t really have scholars of space. You have people who talk about it technologically, and then you have basically people who are boosters. They’re salesmen. They’re, you know, promoting this idea. And so they have this very particular kind of rhetoric about, you know, this is destiny and this is innate curiosity and so on and so forth.
So when the space program actually occurs, and then you’ve got the immediate emergence of space history as kind of a field, is it takes on so much coloration from this. So it’s very triumphalist. It’s very, you know, steely-eyed rocket men and brave astronauts in the capsule, sort of capsule-focused, very technology-focused, and it sort of puts all, submerges all of this broader cultural and background material.
And so by the time you get to the 1980s, you start to see that correct, okay? So you have this new school, this new aerospace history that starts to push back on all of that stuff and establish this different school of thought. Now, the new aerospace history sort of categorized the triumphalist launchpad history, capsule history people as being astrofuturist. And it’s a little bit of a, I wanna say a little bit problematic in a sense because it’s sort of retroactively sketching this school of thought that never really formed as a school of thought. It’s kind of like all of these guys are talking about how it’d be really cool to do this, and then it happens, and then they’re like, “Oh, I guess that was really cool.”
And that’s not a cohesive philosophical point of view. It’s not a cohesive perspective. It’s just all these people were in favor of it, and then they’re writing all the histories, and then it has this very triumphalist tone. And so what that leads to, and this goes along with a lot of the new history and revisionism in history in the late twentieth century, is that you’ve got this sense that this sort of emerging way of describing astrofuturists as being very manifest destiny, very much colonial and sort of turning space exploration into this colonial you know, white male Eurocentric, militaristic, technological objective kind of project, right? And so you’ve got, and that starts fueling a lot of later discussion about, you know, colonialism and space exploration. And so if you take this volume as critical content and just look at that alone then that could be read as a response to this particular astrofuturist approach. And so that’s where these things come together.
I mean, at the risk of going on a tangent, Verne’s book can be read as prophetic of the Apollo program. So to critique Verne is to criticize the Apollo program sort of symbolically or at some sort of, you know, analogical level. And that’s where this becomes an interesting book because it’s about Verne, but also how do we interpret the project of space exploration, and then how does this critical approach contrast with, you know, this prior astrofuturist approach. And this gets back to, you know, my earlier thoughts, is that Verne gets enlisted as astrofuturist sometimes for being this brilliant prophet. But where we run into problems is that Verne himself wasn’t an astrofuturist. He was just a guy who’s like, “Okay, today it’s submarines. Tomorrow it’s hot air balloons. Today it’s idiots with guns, and we need to make this funny.”
Jason Lloyd: It does, I mean, as a touchstone for that astrofuturist way of thinking, it does seem like the motivations that are ascribed to the characters in the book feel very astrofuturist. It’s like, “Yeah, of course we’re gonna go to the moon.” Like, you know, “This is the next step in human destiny. This is the kind of thing that, you know, it hasn’t been done before, so we should take it on.” So is that kind of what astrofuturists are responding to, in addition to, as you mentioned, the prophetic aspects that you could read or misread into the text?
Ryan Faith: I think that’s a lot of it. The similarity in arguments that are presented in the book and the astrofuturist rhetoric actually I think are in some way reflective of space as a subject rather than a sort of a particular genealogy, intellectual heritage. Space exploration is very hard to justify on its returns, okay?
First of all, you don’t know what you’re gonna get because it’s exploration. You know, you can’t think, “I’m gonna discover these six things.” You just don’t know. It’s difficult. It’s very hard. And I think that if you look at the way that space sits in society, let’s say compared to oceans, is space has a lot higher profile than other modes of exploration. So you can’t say it’s just pure curiosity because space outperforms other kinds of exploration. So it’s not innate human nature, innate human curiosity. If you look at the instrumental sort of returns, the ROI, it’s very hard to justify. So a lot of what drives space, I think, is an intrinsic interest in space. It’s sort of intrinsic benefits. We should explore space because we should explore space. And then we try to turn those into rhetorical arguments. They come out as, “Because it’s there, because it’s our destiny.”
If we go back a little bit to the Jackass and MythBusters view of this, why did they do anything? It’s because it was neat. You know, you’ve got really this characteristic like, “Why should we build a gun to the moon?” It’s like, “Because it would be awesome.” Yeah. Like, “Why wouldn’t you?”
Jason Lloyd: “We have this huge gun, you know, what else are we gonna do with it?”
Ryan Faith: Yeah. It’s like, “Even if we don’t have this huge gun, we could have this huge gun. And then we could shoot the moon. And that’d be really cool.” So you’ve got this sort of, it’s inchoate. It’s not very, it’s not very good on an ROI basis. It tends to lend itself, I think, more to mythical language to sort of expressive things. It actually has a lot in common with art.
Vladimir Nabokov, the, the author of Lolita was in New York when the space moon landing happened, and so he didn’t have a TV, but The New York Times rented a TV, brought it to his apartment, and put it on to see what he would say. And he was really skeptical ‘cause he didn’t want these guys coming out and doing this big, like, jock macho moon landing, Stud McStudder kind of stuff. And then he’s watching them, and his … Oh, hold on a sec. I have this written down. It’s a big word. Gesamtkunstwerk, total production. That these are, like, two actors, and then there’s been 400,000 people as part of the stage cast. And this is a piece of sort of total art for society, and was struck by sort of the balletic motion of the astronauts on the surface as they’re going around, and viewed it in this sense. And so there’s a very romantic way to view space exploration.
One of the other guys is like, oh yeah it was Picasso, just said, “I don’t care. This is, this is worthless to me.” But this romantic school of thought is something that emerges with the astrofuturist and emerges with with Verne’s story because we don’t have a lot of tools that are good for talking about why we would want to do space. And so we borrow a lot of that romantic language and that sort of romantic perspective. And so that’s what I think you’re seeing, the resonance between Verne and the astrofuturists.
So when we talk about space exploration as like for instance, let’s say we like to say we do space exploration for science. Okay? That’s a very common argument. It’s like, I can do a lot of science for $10 billion. I can hire a ton of mathematicians and botanists and chemists who don’t have to go to space. So it’s not science qua science, is it? And so you have some people are saying, “Oh, we get special kinds of interdisciplinary interactions in space.” It’s like, well, this starts to sound, to my ear, like the special pleading like, “Oh, well my reason for going to space is okay because it’s unique in some weird space way.” It’s like, so you’re saying it’s intrinsic and unique to space. Oh, that sounds exactly like the romantic argument just dressed in different clothing, that it’s just good because it is. And it’s like, okay.
Jason Lloyd: Yeah. You’ve actually you’ve written for Issues in the past with a great deal of nuance about thinking through the reasons for going to space, and I’m really curious just what is your perspective on it? And you know, recognizing that I really appreciate that you can kind of, um, divide some of these motivations into, in interesting ways. So you have the romantic sense of, like, it’s out there, it’s something we need to explore, maybe human nature to kind of venture into the unknown. So you have that. You have the science rationale of, well, there’s stuff, you know, out there potentially that we don’t, can’t do on Earth, don’t know about. I mean, we’re gonna go do that, do it for that reason.
There’s obviously the geopolitical context of, well, you know, if our competitor gets to space first, you know, for whatever reason, they’re gonna have an advantage, and we need to get up there first. I’m sure there are a whole ton of other rationales. You know, you could … the transhumanist rationale for being a multi-planetary species, I assume, slots into one of those or maybe overlaps a couple. And I’m curious what you think about these rationales. Do you find any of them convincing?
Ryan Faith: So my theory of the universe is that going back to ancient times is that you have the sky is persistent and perfect in some way and unchanging, okay? In a way that’s basically universal across cultures. I mean, the first astronomical records arguably are about 30,000 years old, well into hunter-gatherer, like 10,000, 20,000 years before cultivated land and settling farming, okay? And it was people tracking the moon cycle, how many days we are into the cycle of the moon, okay?
And so what you have is all of these natural processes are occurring around you, that this is the time for this to plant and this is when this animal migrates and this is when this happens and this happens. So you have these, these farmers, for instance, in South America, and it’s like when you see Pleiades rise in the morning above the horizon, then it’s time to plant this crop. So it becomes sort of a Rosetta Stone to unlock natural rhythms and cycles, which you need to sort of actually engage if you’re gonna go eat and not die.
So you’ve got this element. You’ve got the fact that there’s sort of these persistent things that they have this almost sort of supernatural aspect. So you’ve got the very heavy cultural loading going in that’s associated with space throughout history. I did the study and then didn’t take the notes. If you look at flags of the world, basically like 40% of them roughly have the moon or stars on them. Like, the symbology of that appears way more often than anything else, okay? You know, it’s like with the stars and stripes. Like, well, what was that first bit? That was stars, the crescent moon for Islam and all of these things.
So you’ve got this, what I think generates sort of a cultural receptivity to it where it grabs our eye in general ‘cause we’ve got a lot of, you know, language and culture built around that. And so when we get now to the phase, and it starts, really in Ernest, it starts with Galileo, but it gets really underway in Ernest in the nineteenth century where we start looking at planets as destinations and the moon as a destination, like in a very concrete, realistic way, then that sort of changes how we relate to the universe.
And so we’ve been kind of working that out amongst ourselves as a species for a good while now. And this gets back to sort of when you look at what makes art, Brian Eno had a great little bit on this, but it’s sort of like non-functional form. Okay? That we do something that’s above what’s necessary. Like, we have clothes that are all sack cloth, and that is art. Okay? And so when we look at space in a really strictly utilitarian way, we can get communication satellites and we can get GPS. Okay? But when we have moon landings or we’re sending rovers to Mars or building space telescopes, it’s much harder to justify on a strictly utilitarian, pragmatic basis.
And I think that where we’ve created problems with our space exploration debate is that we don’t … we’re not comfortable with saying that maybe this isn’t just a matter of pure dollars and cents. Now, if I can shift gears and switch rhetorically to where today in all of these sort of arguments is I think we’ve got two separate things, and one is everybody and their kid brother has a rationale or a justification for going to space. Okay? The problem is that they’re based on what I like. So if I’m a scientist, I will find science as a very good reason. If I am this person, I will find that reason. So it’s sort of, it’s a blank slate. It’s a tabula rasa. So it says a lot more about what … your justification for space says way more about you than anything about space at all, period, flat out.
And I wrote a paper not too long ago on this talking about how the problem that we face in space is that we don’t know anything about how we would live, how you build societies, how you regulate anything, and so we keep trying to impose our views onto something that’s unknown. Okay? So I think that if we look at the real reason to go to space today is that it seems sensible to guess that the rest of the universe contains something that’s interesting or of relevance to us economically, scientifically, spiritually.
I don’t know. I mean, the universe is a big joint, and there’s a lot of it out there, so there’s probably something. It’d be very foolish to assume there’s nothing out there in the rest of the universe. And so if there’s something that would make that worthwhile, then we should probably figure out what that is and how we want to deal with it. And we can only do that by going into space and first of all figuring out how to live and be and exist in space. You know, how do we get along and all this stuff. You know, it’s just like I should leave my house, I should talk to people, I should live. It’s part of the life process of engaging with your environment.
Jason Lloyd: Yeah. It’s really interesting to hear you talk about just the reasons to go into space in that way because it does seem to a little bit mirror how one might approach this particular text. The text is rich enough that you can pull out a lot of different stuff, but what you’re coming to it with is space travel, you know, this idea about it kind of like a preconceived notion that you’re gonna pull out of it. And so I find that really interesting that, you know, you could read this text in a way that would reflect your feelings about space settlement, space exploration. In a way, I mean, you talk about this at the end of your review, I’m curious, has the Verne novel, you know, the actual story, has that influenced your thinking about space settlement, space exploration in any way?
Ryan Faith: It has in perhaps more indirect ways. One of the things that Klimchynskaya’s volume has is these original etchings from the story. And one of the things they talk about, the Gun Club, is that all of these people in the Gun Club have blown off arms and legs from gun experiments gone awry, okay? That’s part of them just being sort of absurd. And there’s one etching of a guy who’s got two peg legs warming his feet by the fire, okay? And so, you know, he’s clearly going for this sort of absurdist and humorous thing, and I think where what I found interesting is, like, at that point in time, how feasible did people think it was? And at that point, Verne had to create people who were dramatically silly, who were warming their peg legs by the fire, to come up with a group of people who would do this, right?
There’s other parts that I thought were interesting. So for instance, one of the things that we have in modern debates is this debate between sending humans and sending robots, right? And, you know, that’s not really a possibility, you know, until you get into a modern era. You go back to, like, the early 1900s, and there’s a few articles about astronauts versus telescopes, whether or not we should send people or it’s not worth the risk. And so how they talk about the science they were doing at that time, like, these people who come back from the moon trip would be the world’s foremost lunar scientists.
You know, so how it looks from their perspective, how it looks from the perspective of the writing. Verne never heard of Frederick Turner’s Manifest Destiny thesis, right? He’s never seen science fiction. He never got the pulp fiction, you know, in Buck Rogers. And so, like, what’s emerging sort of organically from his perspective, I think gives some insights about how, you know, at least Western culture sort of relates to space in general.
So this is fun stuff in the book, is that the, you know, this coming into this, bringing preconceived notions to it sort of forces Verne into some narrow channels. And it’s unfortunate because Verne’s actually doing, like, a lot of work. There’s a great section about the countries that contribute to the moon cannon. And oh my word, he kinda gives away the game ‘cause the Swiss say there’s never going to make any sense. This is just completely irrational, illogical. So he sort of gives away the game there. For the French, the French at that time were involved in propping up the empire of Mexico, and so they’re involved in their own little colonial misadventures, and he has a, like, little dig there.
I think Verne has a lot of subtext along these lines, a lot of things he kind of pokes at. And it’s an interesting read because he does that, and if we take off the constraints so he can go any direction he wants to go, and we’re not importing a framework into it, he goes off in a lot of directions. And, you know, some good, better, or worse than others, but it’s … I didn’t really appreciate Verne’s scholarship until I read this book, until I did this review. But I can sort of see why people are sort of drawn to it because he covered a lot of ground his, you know, foreground and his background and the subtext, and he’s just doing quite a bit. Enough to where it’s almost worth reading the book and throwing out all the space. And looking at what’s left, ‘cause there’s still a tremendously interesting book there.
Jason Lloyd: Learn more about this tremendously interesting book by reading Ryan’s review of From the Earth to the Moon: Annotated for Our Spacefaring Age in our Fall 2026 issue. You can find links to this and more in our show notes. Thanks to our podcast producer, Kimberly Quach, and our podcast technical director, Roddy Nikpour. I’m Jason Lloyd, managing editor of Issues. Thanks for listening.